Calculate whether a paid community platform (Circle, Skool, Mighty Networks) generates enough revenue to justify the monthly cost based on your membership pricing and expected growth.
Quick answer: This community platform roi calculator helps creators estimate the practical impact, savings potential, or first-year return behind a software decision before pricing pages and marketing claims frame the business case for them.
Use it to pressure-test assumptions, compare scenarios, and build a more grounded case before your decision drifts into abstract marketing claims.
Live calculator
Adjust the assumptions
Example scenario
Creator community on Circle with 50 members
A creator running a $29/month community on Circle ($89/month plan) with 50 paying members and a 7% monthly churn rate.
Why this calculator matters
Community platforms charge $39-119+ per month regardless of how many members you have. At small member counts, the platform fee can eat most of your revenue.
This calculator shows your break-even member count and profit at different scales so you can choose the right platform for your current stage.
Context and practical use
Use this when choosing between community platforms or deciding whether to launch a paid community.
The model focuses on direct membership revenue. If your community also drives course sales, sponsorships, or other revenue, the real ROI is higher than what this calculator shows.
Formula and assumptions
1
Monthly membership revenue = paying members x monthly membership price x (1 - churn rate)
Calculate the return on your newsletter investment — factoring in platform costs, time spent writing, and revenue from sponsorships, paid subscriptions, or affiliate income.
5-8% monthly churn is typical. Below 5% is excellent. Above 10% means members are not finding enough value — focus on engagement before growing.
Should I factor in my time managing the community?
+
This calculator focuses on platform ROI. To include your time, multiply your hours per month by your hourly rate and add it to the platform cost input.